THURSDAY TREATISE by Luke Onyekakeyah – Restoring INEC’s credibility before January 16 election

November 19, 2026
4 views

Amid the on-going political campaigns and other preparations for the 2027 elections across the country, there will be no election in Nigeria without INEC, and there is no trust in Nigeria without a credible INEC. That is the paradox we face as we approach January 16, 2027. The Commission is the referee, the goalkeeper, the linesman and the VAR all at once. And yet, millions of Nigerians no longer believe the referee is neutral.

After the 2023 elections, confidence in INEC collapsed. According to Afrobarometer, trust in INEC fell from 55 percent in 2021 to 28 percent in 2023. The reason was not just who won or lost. It was how results were managed. The promise of real-time transmission of polling unit results on IReV was the single biggest reform Nigerians had celebrated since the introduction of the card reader. On election night, it failed.

Prof. Mahmood Yakubu’s excuse – a “technical glitch” – became the most expensive phrase in our electoral history. It cost INEC its reputation. It cost the judiciary its peace. It cost Nigeria its belief that votes truly count.

Now, under a new Chairman, Prof. Joash Amupitan, INEC has one last chance to rebuild that trust before 2027. The question is not whether INEC can conduct elections. We know it can. The question is whether Nigerians will believe the results it announces. INEC’s credibility did not die in one day. It died in three places.

First, is the technology promise. IReV was sold as the antidote to rigging. When it was not used for the presidential election but worked for National Assembly elections hours later, suspicion turned to certainty in the minds of many. Technology that works selectively is worse than no technology at all.

Second, in personnel recruitment. Collation officers, returning officers, ad-hoc staff – many Nigerians believe these are not neutral academics but appointees of governors and party chieftains. In 2023, in several states, resident electoral commissioners were openly accused of partisanship. When the umpire is perceived as a player, the game is already lost.

Third, in communication. INEC went silent for too long on election night in 2023. In a digital age, silence is not neutrality. Silence is a vacuum that conspiracy theories fill in seconds. While INEC waited for results to trickle in, WhatsApp, X and TikTok announced their own results. INEC lost the narrative before it lost the election.

How Amupitan can restore it. The new Chairman has started well. His first three moves – the joint financial monitoring war-room with EFCC, ICPC and NFIU, the Osun-model secrecy cubicle nationwide, and the public pledge to transmit results live – are credible. But promises are cheap. Credibility is built on verifiable actions.

1. Make IReV non-negotiable and test it publicly. INEC must do what it refused to do in 2023: conduct a nationwide mock transmission, live on television, with civil society and the media watching. Upload dummy results from all 36 states plus FCT, and let Nigerians see the system work under stress. The Electoral Act 2026 now makes electronic transmission mandatory. INEC must say publicly: “If a polling unit result is not on IReV within 30 minutes of declaration, that result will not be collated.” That one sentence will restore more confidence than 100 press conferences.

2. Clean the house of personnel.  INEC must publish the full list of all Returning Officers, Collation Officers and RECs for 2027 by December 2026, with their affiliations declared. Any REC who has been a party member, a former commissioner, or a political appointee within the last 10 years must be redeployed. Nigeria has thousands of retired judges, professors and senior civil servants who are neutral. Use them.

3. Open the collation centres. Collation is where rigging lives. In 2027, every ward, local government and state collation centre must be streamed live on INEC’s YouTube and on national TV. Party agents, observers and journalists must have unrestricted access. No collation in darkness. No results announced at 3am without cameras. The moment collation becomes a public theatre, manipulation becomes impossible.

4. Prosecute INEC’s own offenders. The greatest signal of reform would be to prosecute INEC staff who compromised 2023. The Commission admitted that some of its officials were complicit in some states. How many were sacked? How many were jailed? Zero public convictions. If INEC cannot punish its own, it cannot punish politicians.

The credibility test is not on Election Day. It is now. INEC does not earn credibility on January 16. It earns it in November, December and early January, by the transparency of its preparations. Nigerians are watching the recruitment of ad-hoc staff, the distribution of PVCs, the deployment of sensitive materials, and the testing of BVAS. If those processes are open, the result will be accepted, even by losers.

Credibility is not neutrality. It is provable neutrality. If Prof. Amupitan succeeds, he will not just conduct an election. He will restore the faith that a ballot in Abakaliki counts as much as a ballot in Abuja. If he fails, 2027 will be the election that finally breaks Nigeria’s faith in the ballot box itself. And a country that no longer believes in ballots will believe in bullets. We cannot afford that.

Dr. Onyekakeyah, former member of The Guardian Editorial Board, is a public affairs commentator and columnist for Daily Query.

 

 

 

Don't Miss