IBSIF – A regulator’s audacious push for a better telecom industry

November 18, 2026
10 views

By Okoh Aihe

The Incentive-Based Spectrum Investment Framework (IBSIF) introduced last week by the Nigerian Communications Commission (NCC) is not novel although creatively directed at ensuring more efficient and accountable use of spectrum to deliver more benefits to the various stakeholders, including subscribers in far-flung places.

It means therefore that much more considerations will be given to spectrum assignment, service rollout and deployment to the various markets.

Spectrum is a finite resource and is held dearly across the nations of the world. In Nigeria spectrum management falls under the purview of the National Frequency Management Council (NFMC), which is domiciled in the Ministry of Communications, Innovation and Digital Economy.

Spectrum is a finite resource. Globally, the ITU Radiocommunicaton Sector (ITU-R) with support from the Radiocommunication Bureau (BR) is the arm of the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) responsible for the global management and allocation of radio-frequency spectrum and satellite orbit resources.

Universally, spectrum is taken as a scarce resource and its deployment must be strategic and efficient. So, telecom regulators are very intentional and even miserly when they measure it out for sale and usage. Since the 2001 GSM auction in Nigeria which yielded a record sum of $855m to the federation account, spectrum has attracted so much attention which makes it a low-hanging fruit for any government in power in need of some urgent fund.

Such money in the federation account is forked out to the Federal government, the States and Local Government Areas on an agreed sharing formula. The GSM money was a major windfall to the Olusegun Obasanjo government.
However, the telecom regulator has now introduced the Incentive-Based Spectrum Investment Framework (IBSIF) which it says, “represents a deliberate and strategic approach to spectrum management, recognizing that spectrum, as a valuable national resource, can deliver benefits beyond the immediate revenues generated through licensing.”

The Framework, the regulator further explained, seeks to link appropriate spectrum-related incentives to additional, measurable and enforceable investment in telecommunications infrastructure, encouraging operators to expand coverage, increase network capacity and improve service quality.

Here is the new take. Spectrum may not have to attract its astronomical cost any more just to make the various governments happy but actually costed and assigned so creatively to make it respond first to the advantage of service rollout, availability in whatever area, and affordable cost to stakeholders before every other consideration.

In this wise, the NCC will need to be able to explain to relevant arms of government that it is not a revenue generating agency as they were led to believe under the previous administration but a regulator that should put many things in a scale to weigh in favour of service availability for the people rather than a few greedy guys waiting to share the pile.

Don’t get confused. The 2001 GSM auction money went to the federation account. It was quickly shared without using any part of it to dress up the industry for the coming licensees. The result: network congestion from the beginning and the situation has hardly abated.

The regulator under the Buhari administration was pressured to do two 5G auctions in less than two years in contravention of an auction moratorium it placed on itself. I am not competent to state what happened to the money except to sketch that it went to the federation account after it has been shaved of all sorts of ancillary expenses.

I am saying here that the first assignment the regulator will need to do concerning this pet project of IBSIF is to convince the government, of which it is a part, why its new spectrum plan is the way to go.

Other jurisdictions also need money but they have been able to tame their greed for the sake of tomorrow’s development. The regulator gave the example of Brazil which has been able to incorporate investment and coverage obligations into its 5G spectrum assignment arrangements. Its successful experience illustrates how spectrum licensing can support accelerated network expansion when linked to clearly defined investment commitments, the NCC pointed out.

Let me add what I may consider a more befitting example clearly very indicative of what happens when service deployment and availability weigh more in the hearts of government and the regulatory agency than a few quick bucks that easily get consumed in greedy mastication.

At the same time that Nigeria was conducting its 5G auction in 2022, India was also doing one. While Nigeria raked in $547m, India attracted a whopping $19bn. Let me quickly add here that while India put out over 70 spectrum mix in the market, Nigeria had only three spectrum lots. I have been told that India has a huge population of about 1.47 billion which is far more than the population of Nigeria which stands at about 244 million. But the choices were different and so were the documentations.

Major winners in India were: Reliance Jio – $11bn, Bharti Airtel – $5.4bn, Vodafone Idea – $2.4bn, and Adani Group – $27m. In Nigeria, it was MTN and Mafab with each paying $273.6m.

While in India, the winners were made to pay a percentage of the fee or nothing at all, with the entire fee spread over a 20 year period, which is the duration of the license in equal annual instalments at 7.2 percent interest rate, the Nigerian winners were given a period to pay the license fee into the federation account for the money to be shared immediately with tomorrow left hanging.

India demonstrated an incredibly imaginative process which placed more importance on the people, service rollout and service delivery and availability. The results speak for themselves. According to the NCC, 5G population coverage in Nigeria, as at April 2026, stands at 13 percent. It is not out of place here to observe that this kind of growth has hardly moved a needle.

Within the same period, India has nearly achieved a universal 5G coverage with the technology reaching over 99.6 percent of districts nationwide. More than 469,000 5G base stations are deployed across the states and union territories.

What then is the difference? Clarity and focus. Instead of collecting license money upfront and cause operators to labour in rolling out services, the regulator – Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI), on behalf of the country, made a clear choice – to forgo the comfort which the license money would offer today for the development of a tomorrow which brings a more lasting comfort for all the stakeholders. The auction document is very instructive. Why do we always go for the easy money instead of more detailed planning for better outcomes? It is difficult to understand or even explain.

Does it come as a surprise therefore that years after paying a hefty license fee, new entrant, Mafab, is offering for sale its spectrum assets to MTN? Such a possibility was sketched in this column long ago. Imagine if that amount was allowed to be invested in the industry instead of being consumed upfront!

Drawing a conclusion for this writing, I want to affirm that the regulator has made a better and more forward-looking choice with the introduction of IBSIF. It only needs our prayers and all necessary enablement to create a better telecommunications industry where broadband is resilient and pervasive, service available in good quality, and where modern technology, including AI, is less of a mystery than reality.

Don't Miss