“People can follow a decision they disagree with, but they rarely follow a leader they no longer trust.”
1. The Story
A newly elected leader of a respected Subcouncil was admired for his deep spirituality and strong commitment to prayer. He frequently reminded members that every important decision he made was under the guidance of the Holy Spirit.
Initially, his Executive welcomed this approach. After all, every Christian leader should seek God’s wisdom before making decisions. Gradually, however, a different pattern emerged. Executive meetings became less of a forum for discussion and more of a platform for announcements. Members found that opportunities to contribute were limited. Questions were often brushed aside. Alternative views were seldom entertained.
Whenever important matters arose, the explanation was usually the same – “I am acting under the guidance of the Holy Spirit.” Over time, Executive members began to feel that their experience, ideas, and wisdom no longer mattered. Conversations that should have taken place around the meeting table gradually moved into corridors and private discussions. Questions turned into doubts. Doubts became suspicions. Suspicions weakened trust.
The younger members, who had once attended meetings with enthusiasm, quietly began to stay away. They were not protesting loudly. They simply stopped coming. The greatest loss was not attendance. It was confidence.
2. The Leadership Lesson
Spiritual leadership and transparent leadership are not opposites. They are partners. Seeking God’s guidance should never prevent a leader from listening to the wisdom that God may provide through other people.
One of the greatest mistakes any leader can make is to confuse consultation with weakness. The strongest leaders invite honest contributions, encourage respectful disagreement, and explain the reasoning behind important decisions. They understand that openness strengthens trust.
When leaders consistently shut others out of meaningful participation, people begin to create their own explanations. In the absence of communication, suspicion fills the vacuum.
Trust is the currency of leadership. Once trust begins to diminish, attendance declines, commitment weakens, and even the noblest vision struggles to inspire. Leadership is not about making every decision by committee, but it is about ensuring that people feel heard, respected, and valued. A leader who closes the door to participation eventually finds that people stop knocking.
3. Practical Application
This week, examine your own leadership. Ask yourself –
● Do people feel free to express their views around me?
● Do I explain important decisions clearly and honestly?
● Have I mistaken consultation for a lack of authority?
● Am I building trust through openness or unintentionally creating suspicion through silence?
● Do people leave meetings feeling included or merely informed?
Whether in the family, workplace, Church, or voluntary organizations, transparency does not weaken leadership, it strengthens it. People may not always agree with your decisions, but they will more readily support them when they understand that they were made with integrity, openness, and respect.
4. Reflection
The issue is not that a leader seeks God’s guidance. Every faith-based leader should. The real problem is when appealing to divine guidance becomes a substitute for openness, accountability, consultation, and collective wisdom. This reflection sufficiently makes it clear that using that claim to avoid accountability, consultation, or transparency should never be encouraged. Leadership does not lose authority by listening; it loses credibility by refusing to listen. When leaders stop opening their hearts to people, people quietly begin closing their hearts to the leader.
5. Leadership Challenge
This week, open a door that you may have unknowingly closed. Invite someone you lead to tell you what they genuinely think, not what they believe you want to hear. Ask for an opinion you may not agree with. Listen to a concern without becoming defensive. And when someone respectfully challenges your position, resist the instinct to interpret disagreement as disloyalty.
If you are a faith-based leader, pray for guidance, but also remain humble enough to recognize that wisdom can come through the people around you. Before your next important decision, ask – “Who have I listened to?” “Whose perspective have I not heard?” “What might I be missing?” You do not have to surrender your authority because you listened. Listen first. Decide wisely. Explain honestly. And lead humbly. Remember, consultation does not diminish leadership. It enriches it.
6. Questions for Personal Reflection
* Do people around me feel genuinely free to disagree with me?
* When someone challenges my position, do I listen for wisdom or immediately defend myself?
* Have I ever used my position, spirituality, experience, or authority to end a conversation rather than engage with it?
* Do I sometimes make decisions privately and merely announce them publicly?
* When I say I have prayed about a decision, am I still open to the counsel and perspectives of others?
* Could people approach me with an uncomfortable truth without fearing my reaction?
* Have people around me become silent, not because they agree, but because they no longer believe speaking will make a difference?
* Do I explain important decisions sufficiently, or do I expect people to accept them simply because I am the leader?
* What happens to trust when people are repeatedly informed but rarely consulted?
* Is there a door I need to reopen, perhaps to dialogue, reconciliation, consultation, or honest conversation?
7. Closing Thoughts
Leadership is not a closed room where one voice speaks and everyone else listens. It is a table where wisdom is welcomed, truth is respected, and people know that their voices matter. A leader may have the final authority to decide, but that does not mean he possesses the final wisdom.
Prayer is essential. Conviction is important. Authority has its place. But humility must stand at the centre of them all. The leader who listens does not become weaker. The leader who consults does not become smaller. The leader who welcomes disagreement does not surrender authority. Rather, such a leader demonstrates the confidence to hear what others have to say before making the decision he is ultimately responsible for.
And perhaps this is the deeper lesson – you can close the door and still make decisions. But you cannot close the door indefinitely and expect trust to remain outside waiting for you. When leaders stop listening, people eventually stop speaking. When people stop speaking, leaders lose access to the truth. And when leaders lose access to the truth, they may still have authority, but they begin to lead without the wisdom of the people they are called to serve. Keep the door open. Keep the conversation alive. Keep your heart humble. For sometimes, the voice you are tempted to silence may be the very voice you need to hear.
Your comments please
0803 308 3989
danuzoegwu2003@yahoo.com
