The uncrowned sovereigns and the tragedy of the near-miss in African democracy
On October 15, 2025, Kenya lost one of the most consequential political figures in its modern history. Raila Amolo Odinga, former prime minister, five-time presidential contender and one of Africa’s most recognisable opposition leaders, died in India at the age of 80. His death brought an end to a political journey defined by extraordinary influence, repeated disappointment and an almost stubborn refusal to leave the centre of public life.
Across the continent, another political heavyweight is approaching the same age. Atiku Abubakar, Nigeria’s former vice-president, turns 80 on November 25. He has spent decades navigating the corridors of power, building alliances, challenging governments and pursuing a presidency that has remained frustratingly beyond his reach. His latest attempt, under the African Democratic Congress, has already encountered a serious legal obstacle.
The question is therefore worth asking: Is Atiku Abubakar Nigeria’s Raila Odinga?
The comparison is tempting, but it deserves more than a superficial examination of two men who repeatedly sought the highest office in their countries and never occupied it. Their stories reveal something deeper about African politics: the peculiar power of politicians who can shape the direction of national politics, influence who becomes president and command formidable political followings, yet struggle to convert that influence into personal electoral victory.
They were, in different ways, uncrowned political sovereigns.
Raila’s political inheritance was unmistakable. He was the son of Jaramogi Oginga Odinga, Kenya’s first vice-president and a prominent figure in the country’s independence struggle. But his own political identity was forged through confrontation with authoritarian rule. Accused of involvement in the failed 1982 coup attempt, he was detained without trial for six years. Further detentions followed, and in 1991 he went into exile in Norway as Kenya’s one-party political order came under increasing pressure.
His struggle became part of the wider movement that eventually restored multiparty democracy in Kenya. He returned to a country whose political landscape was changing, entered electoral politics and became one of its most formidable opposition figures. His story was not simply that of a politician seeking office. It was also the story of a man who had endured imprisonment and exile in the struggle over the political future of his country.
Atiku’s route into national politics was different. Born in Jada, present-day Adamawa State, he built his early career in the Nigeria Customs Service before moving into business and politics. His political rise was closely associated with the political network around Shehu Musa Yar’Adua and the democratic transition of the early 1990s.
In 1993, Atiku sought the presidential ticket of the Social Democratic Party. He later won the governorship election in Adamawa State in 1999 but stepped aside before taking office to become the running mate to Olusegun Obasanjo. He served as vice-president from 1999 to 2007, a period that gave him a front-row seat to the workings of presidential power and, eventually, a bitter confrontation with the man with whom he had governed.
That experience matters. Raila spent much of his political life trying to enter the executive centre of power. Atiku spent eight years inside it. One was shaped by detention, opposition and resistance to an authoritarian state; the other by the opportunities and conflicts of Nigeria’s democratic political establishment. Their backgrounds are not interchangeable, and pretending otherwise would weaken the comparison.
Yet both men discovered that political influence and presidential victory are not the same thing.
Perhaps the clearest illustration of Raila’s political genius came in 2002. Kenya’s ruling KANU party was preparing to retain power after President Daniel arap Moi endorsed Uhuru Kenyatta as his preferred successor. The opposition was divided, and the prospect of another KANU victory was real.
Raila made a consequential choice. Rather than insist on his own presidential ambition, he threw his weight behind Mwai Kibaki. His declaration, “Kibaki Tosha” Kibaki is enough became one of the defining political moments of that election. Raila helped bring the Liberal Democratic Party into an alliance with Kibaki’s National Alliance of Kenya, forming the National Rainbow Coalition. The opposition united, defeated KANU and ended its long hold on power.
Raila had helped deliver the presidency to another man. It was an extraordinary demonstration of political influence, but it also revealed the dilemma that would follow him: he could help determine who occupied State House without becoming its occupant himself.
Atiku’s relationship with the formation of Nigeria’s opposition coalition offers a comparison, although not an identical one. The All Progressives Congress was formed in February 2013 through the merger of the Action Congress of Nigeria, Congress for Progressive Change, All Nigeria Peoples Party and a faction of the All Progressives Grand Alliance. Atiku joined the APC in November that year, months after its formation, as part of the wider political movement away from the Peoples Democratic Party.
The distinction is important. Atiku did not create the original merger. But his defection added weight to an opposition realignment that would eventually produce the first defeat of an incumbent ruling party in Nigeria’s presidential election. In 2015, Muhammadu Buhari won, while Atiku was not the candidate around whom the coalition had united.
There is a difference between helping to build a coalition around a candidate and building one around oneself. Raila’s “Kibaki Tosha” moment was a direct and decisive act of opposition consolidation. Atiku’s place in the APC story was different: he joined an existing merger and contributed to the broader opposition movement. Yet both episodes expose the same political difficulty. The capacity to influence the route to power does not automatically provide a route to the presidency.
Their subsequent political journeys made that difficulty even more apparent.
Raila contested the Kenyan presidency in 1997, 2007, 2013, 2017 and 2022. Five attempts, five disappointments. But his political career cannot be measured only by the election results. His disputed defeat in 2007 plunged Kenya into a devastating crisis. The violence that followed the announcement of the result left more than a thousand people dead and displaced hundreds of thousands. A power-sharing agreement, brokered with the involvement of former United Nations Secretary-General Kofi Annan, made Raila prime minister in a coalition government with Kibaki.
He finally entered the highest level of executive government, but not as president. The arrangement brought a measure of stability after a national catastrophe, although tensions within the coalition persisted. During that period, Kenya adopted its 2010 Constitution, a major national reform that devolved power to 47 counties, strengthened institutions and reshaped the country’s constitutional order. Raila was part of the political leadership of that period, though the achievement belonged to a much wider national process.
Atiku’s presidential journey has been equally persistent, though its milestones are different. He sought the SDP nomination in 1993, contested the 2007 presidential election, pursued party tickets in 2011 and 2014, and contested the general elections of 2019 and 2023. He has moved between political parties as alliances shifted and ambitions collided: from the PDP to the Action Congress, to the APC, back to the PDP and, more recently, the ADC.
His movement across parties has often been criticised as political opportunism. His supporters may describe it as the pragmatism required to remain relevant in a political system where party structures, elite bargains and shifting alliances frequently determine who gets a realistic chance of competing. Either way, the pattern has made him one of Nigeria’s most enduring political figures.
But endurance has not delivered the presidency.
In 2019, Atiku challenged Muhammadu Buhari’s victory in court. In 2023, he again challenged the result, this time against Bola Tinubu. The courts rejected his petitions. These experiences bear a resemblance to Raila’s repeated electoral disputes, particularly his 2017 challenge, when Kenya’s Supreme Court annulled the presidential election and ordered a fresh poll. But the outcomes and political circumstances were not the same. Raila’s 2017 petition produced a 76historic judicial decision; Atiku’s challenges did not overturn the declared results.
The similarities, therefore, should not obscure the differences. Raila became a central figure in Kenya’s struggle against one-party rule and constitutional reform. Atiku’s political career has been more closely tied to Nigeria’s party structures, elite negotiations and the contest for control of the federal government. Raila’s influence often came from mass mobilisation and his ability to unite disparate political forces. Atiku’s has rested heavily on political networks, organisation, alliances and his long experience within the establishment.
Both men, however, understood the value of remaining politically relevant even after defeat. Neither accepted electoral disappointment as an instruction to disappear.
Raila’s final years demonstrated this quality. Even after five unsuccessful presidential campaigns, he remained a major national and continental figure. In 2025, he contested the chairmanship of the African Union Commission, losing to Djibouti’s Mahmoud Ali Youssouf. He subsequently entered into a cooperation agreement with President William Ruto, another reminder of his capacity to move between opposition and political accommodation. His death closed a remarkable chapter in Kenyan politics, but it did not erase the influence he had accumulated over decades.
Atiku, meanwhile, is still pursuing the office that has eluded him. He secured the ADC presidential ticket in May 2026 for what would be his seventh presidential bid, counting his 1993 party-primary attempt. But on November 5, a Federal High Court judgment invalidated the David Mark-led ADC leadership structure and the actions taken under it, including the process that produced Atiku’s nomination. The party rejected the judgment and indicated that it would challenge it in the Court of Appeal. The legal position is therefore contested, and the nomination cannot responsibly be treated as beyond dispute.
That development places Atiku at another political crossroads. At nearly 80, he must contend not only with the challenge of persuading Nigerians that he remains the right person to lead them, but also with the legal and organisational questions surrounding the platform on which he intends to contest.
There is a lesson in Raila’s life that goes beyond the number of times a politician contests an election. Political longevity is not necessarily political achievement, and persistence is not automatically proof of destiny. A politician may become indispensable to national conversations without becoming indispensable to the nation’s future. The ability to command attention, negotiate alliances and mobilise supporters is valuable, but it must eventually answer to a more demanding question: what does the country gain from all that influence?
Raila’s legacy will remain a subject of debate. His supporters remember a man who challenged authoritarianism, endured detention and helped shape Kenya’s democratic transition. His critics will assess the compromises, alliances and political calculations that accompanied his long career. But few can deny that he altered the course of Kenyan politics without ever becoming president.
Atiku’s record must be judged on its own terms. His years as vice-president, his role in party politics and his repeated presidential contests have made him one of the most influential figures in Nigeria’s Fourth Republic. Yet the presidency remains the missing chapter. The question confronting him is whether another campaign can overcome the political, institutional and public doubts that have followed his previous attempts.
So, is Atiku Abubakar Nigeria’s Raila Odinga?
In political temperament, persistence and the experience of remaining consequential without reaching the presidency, the resemblance is striking. But Raila’s place in Kenya’s democratic struggle was shaped by a particular history of resistance, detention, mass mobilisation and constitutional change. Atiku’s story belongs to a different political tradition, one defined by executive experience, elite alliances, party realignments and an enduring pursuit of presidential power.
They are not the same man, and their legacies should not be made identical for the convenience of a headline.
Yet the comparison raises a question that both careers leave behind: what does it mean to wield enormous political influence for decades and still remain outside the highest office?
Perhaps that is the tragedy of the near-miss. To come close enough to shape the fortunes of presidents, to command the loyalty of political constituencies and to remain a central figure in national affairs, yet never quite cross the final threshold.
Raila Odinga has taken his final bow. Atiku Abubakar is still on the political stage. Whether he will make one last journey to the presidency remains uncertain. But history will not judge either man simply by the office he failed to occupy. It will judge what he did with the influence he possessed, the democratic space he helped shape and the political future he left behind.
The presidency may be the highest office in a democracy. It is not the only measure of a political life.
Shaakaa can be reached on: shaakaastephanie@yahoo.com









